Enbridge Gateway Hearings Rhetoric Heats Up

By B. McPherson
This is some of the environment that would be put at risk with oil tankers traversing the treacherous seaways.


Native elders and chiefs spoke in Kitimaat Village today regarding the proposed routing of the Gateway twinned pipelines through the Great Bear Rain Forest to the west coast of British Columbia.

One of the Chiefs who spoke today expressed concern regarding the routing of the pipeline, likening the risk to his people as a double-barrelled shotgun. Pipeline spills through the sensitive land area plus the hundreds of oil laden tankers threading their way through the twisted canal leading to the town of Kitimat are very real dangers to the pristine environment.

The Haisla are facing a double-barrelled shotgun by the bringing of that oil by pipeline and shipping it by sea," Hereditary Chief Ken Hall told the opening day of environmental hearings into the project.
"The pipeline threatens our grandchildren," he said Tuesday. "It's going to be terrifying if everything disappears in our community." Canadian Business

The First Nations people acknowledged the importance of jobs for the duration of the build out, but pointed out that there is a responsibility to those who come after them. Currently, much of the BC coastal waters are clean enough to harvest shellfish. Fishing is still bountiful in many areas. An oil spill of crude oil in the cold waters would continue to pollute for many years ruining shell fish beds, crab harvesting and killing many other wildlife.

Warmer waters support bacteria and other organisms that help to break down petroleum products quickly compared to the cold waters of the coast. An oil tanker run aground leaving Alaska(Exxon Valdez) is still polluting water after more than 20 years. That calamity was not blamed on equipment failure. It was attributed to the captain’s actions.

A more recent shipping accident saw a government ferry go aground and sink. While it was not a tanker, enough oil is escaping to compromise local beaches. Again, it was not attributed to equipment failure but human error.

The potential for huge monetary returns in selling this oil are real. The pool of oil in Alberta rivals that of the Saudi reserves. The effort to develop the Alberta oil sands is a multi-national effort that includes corporations from China, Norway, Holland, France, USA as well as Canadian companies.

Knowing that trillions upon trillions of dollars in profit are expected by all the shareholders once the oil starts to flow, it is one step short of lunacy to not demand the pipeline follow the safest route to the coast as well as making sure that it is built to the highest possible standards throughout. It is most unfortunate that the federal minister for Natural Resources, Joe Oliver, compromised the neutrality of the hearings before they started by labelling those in opposition to the route or the safety of the pipelines as radicals and foreign special interest groups. Neither should a decision be foisted onto the backs of the people of British Columbia who will be taking all the environmental risks with very little share of the rewards. 
Location: Princess Royal Island, British Columbia, Canada

Comments

  1. Instant Internet Lifestyle Review12 January 2012 at 20:30

    Isn't it interesting that, while everyone KNOWS we must quit our petroleum dependence,we keep taking the 'easy' way out and finding dirtier and more dangerous ways to drill or process oil - rather than invent clean, efficient new technology. Coincidental, isn't it, that those oil companies manage to hang on to their monopoly . . . and their profits . . . at the expense of our futures.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Prince Rupert Says No to Enbridge Pipeline

Image
B. McPherson Prince Rupert city council joined a growing list of BC coastal communities that are saying “No” to the Enbridge proposal to build a twinned pipeline from Edmonton to the coast. The decision of the Prince Rupert city politicians was unanimous. Already the village of Kitimaat, Terrace and the Skeena Queen Charlottes Regional District have voiced their opposition to the project. There are ongoing hearings by a federal court appointed Joint Review Panel which are gathering input from interested parties about the proposed Enbridge Northern Gateway Pipeline which would bring crude petroleum from the oil sands of Alberta to the coast of British Columbia. The proposal would see a twinned pipeline run over the Rocky Mountains and through wilderness to the treacherous west coast. The proposed terminus at Kitimat would require tankers to wend their way through the maze of islands and reefs to load up at the head of Douglas Channel. While the hearings and the finding
Read more

Abandoned Oil Pipelines What Lurks Below?

Image
These photos were taken July 2012 in the historic Turner Valley, Alberta B. McPherson Controversy over new oil pipelines is reaching boiling point in many circles. Heated debate is taking place over the proposed Enbridge Northern Gateway and Keystone Pipeline proposals. Safety, disruption to landowners  and more are being weighed against the money to be made transporting and selling petroleum products. It got me thinking about the old pipelines. What happens to a pipeline when it is too old to use or not needed? It’s a bit of an Alice in Wonderland scene. The US laws and regulations are different from ours in Canada. The Pipeline and Gas Journal is a source of information about abandoned pipelines in Texas. Apparently a pipeline in Texas may be abandoned by a company, but it still retains ownership and may choose to reactivate the line at a later date. In the meantime, the right of way or easement is no longer maintained, but the through which the pipe extends is not free
Read more

Efficient Rail Transport May Make Pipelines Obsolete

Image
B. McPherson What happens to all the abandoned pipelines? Oil pipelines have huge direct costs to build, but they also have many hidden costs. In spite of dire warnings by environmentalist the world is demanding ever greater supplies of the black gold. For those countries that have it and market it successfully, money comes rolling in. But at what cost? An oil pipeline is a hugely complex thing. Enbridge Corp. has been battling citizens in British Columbia over its proposed Northern Gateway Pipeline and the Keystone Pipeline in the US has been stalled for months. When Big Oil needs to transport oil or bitumen to refineries, it usually gets a smooth ride to approval. Labelling energy security as a national priority, property rights are infringed upon. People in Canada cannot legally stop the installation of a pipeline across their property. The high pressure conduit is often buried only a few feet below the surface leaving crops, buildings and livestock vulnerable to a
Read more